Government contracts attorney Eric Crusius explains GAO’s September 21, 2026 denial of a protest of the Army’s $50 billion MAPS vehicle. GAO upheld the Army’s bonus evaluation points for third-party CMMC certification, and it declined to consider whether the Phase 2 suspension undermined them because the protester raised that argument too late. Eric and the hosts discuss whether bonus points could let the DoD encourage certification without making it a condition of award.
Key Takeaways
- GAO upheld bonus points. Scoring that rewards certification reasonably relates to the agency’s needs, even though certification isn’t mandatory.
- The suspension argument was too late. GAO didn’t rule on it, but it encouraged the Army to reconsider the bonus points if it amends the solicitation.
- GAO decisions act as precedent, though facts matter. Eric calls this one a “permission slip.”
- Incentives work as de facto requirements. A small scoring edge can decide close awards, so companies will get certified anyway.
- The DoD could extend the approach, but Level 3 is harder because DIBCAC capacity is limited, while Level 2 C3PAO assessments are widely available.
- Contractors should act early. Share solicitations with compliance and legal during the RFI stage so a certification advantage doesn’t surprise you.
Transcript
GAO’s CMMC Decision and the Phase 2 Suspension
Jacob: All right, folks. It’s October 2026. On September 21st, GAO denied a protest involving the Army’s $50 billion MAPS contracting vehicle. One protester challenged the Army’s decision to award bonus evaluation points to contractors that had obtained, or were pursuing, third-party CMMC certification. The protester argued this unfairly favored early adopters because certification wasn’t yet mandatory. GAO disagreed, finding that the scoring reasonably related to the Army’s anticipated needs.
But there’s a twist. After the Army issued the solicitation, the DoD suspended Phase 2 of CMMC, including mandatory third-party requirements. GAO declined to consider whether the suspension undermined the Army’s bonus point system, because the protester raised the argument too late. GAO explicitly encouraged the Army to reconsider bonus points for CMMC certification if it amends the solicitation in the future. That’s what we’re going to talk about today with the great and powerful Eric Crusius.
Jason, this is an interesting story, and it leads to a bigger question. Can the DoD require CMMC certification by making it a competitive advantage rather than a straight-up mandatory requirement? That would give the DoD a sort of out. It would incentivize certification without technically requiring it.
Jason: Jacob, you’re asking me a bunch of questions I’m not qualified to answer, but I know somebody who is. Our good friend Eric is joining us this week. Before we get into all the questions about this challenge and protest, why don’t you introduce yourself, Eric?
Eric: Sure. First of all, great to be here. Jacob called me powerful, and I’ll remind my children of that, because sometimes they forget. Many folks know me for my work in the CMMC ecosystem, but most of my practice is devoted to helping government contractors, whether on compliance or on filing a protest. I have a lot of background in the protest space, especially where it mixes with cybersecurity. You may remember my SPRS protest a few years ago on whether SPRS scores are required. Those are always fun, and I’m honored to be here to discuss this case.
Why the Army’s $50 Billion MAPS Contract Drew Protests
Jason: Let’s get right to it, Eric. This conversation centers on MAPS and the fact that it attracted a wave of protests. Is that routine for a $50 billion contract vehicle, or does it suggest that something went wrong along the way?
Eric: No. Every large vehicle for the most part attracts protests, because the stakes are so high and companies see a huge potential revenue stream. They’re willing to spend money on attorneys to file a protest. Sometimes companies do it themselves, but that’s usually not advisable, much like performing surgery on yourself. Every large procurement usually attracts at least a few protests, so seeing a few on a procurement like this isn’t surprising and doesn’t necessarily indicate something wrong, although there were some interesting twists and turns in this one.
Jacob: We haven’t covered protests on the show much, because I haven’t seen many related to CMMC directly, since it’s been in rulemaking for so long. This protest covers a lot: multiple companies and multiple complaints. It isn’t labeled “we don’t like CMMC, here’s what you should do.” The CMMC issue is buried pretty far into the document.
Did GAO Set a Precedent for CMMC Bonus Points?
Jacob: What did GAO actually decide about CMMC bonus points? And do protests create precedent? If GAO says this was an okay approach, is it an okay approach for everybody going forward?
Eric: I’ll answer your second question first. For the most part, yes. GAO sets precedent. When you file a protest, you cite previous GAO cases that support your position, and GAO attorneys are fairly well constrained by them. But each factual situation is a little different, sometimes different enough to let a GAO attorney not follow the precedent. It’s very similar to courts. So yes, it’s precedent, but it may be limited by the facts and circumstances. If I were filing a protest on this issue, I’d cite this case and analogize my facts to these. At a broad level, it supports the idea that solicitations can include non-statutory, non-regulatory requirements. Here, the protesters were challenging many different things in the procurement, with CMMC being one of them. But I think it’s a permission slip, potentially.
Jacob: The MAPS contract was structured so that it wanted a CMMC Level 2 self-assessment but gave you points if you had a certification. Since it’s a vehicle, I assume task orders are issued underneath it. So all things being equal, if I have a Level 2 self-assessment and you have a Level 2 certification, you’d get more points for the cert. Am I understanding that correctly?
Eric: Yes. And you’re seeing this more and more in government contracting. The government is trying to avoid protests on every order or contract action, so it establishes large multiple-award contracts and selects a pool. Having a pool of folks already on the contract discourages protests on individual orders. Plus, task order protests are limited. They can’t be filed at the Court of Federal Claims, which agencies like to stay away from, and that’s a statutory rule. Small awards, like $5 or $10 million, aren’t protestable. This is a theme in government contracting: the government is moving toward larger procurements for efficiency, but also to avoid protests, at the Court of Federal Claims in particular and sometimes even at GAO. Sorry, Jacob, go ahead.
When Does a Certification Incentive Become a Requirement?
Jacob: There’s a sliding scale of bonus points based on the status you achieve: self-assessment, Level 2 certification, Level 3. For otherwise identical contractors, that can decide who gets the work. I don’t think GAO gets into this in the decision, but is this an incentive or a de facto requirement? If certification determines who wins, can you even call them bonus points? At that point it’s the thing they’re deciding on.
Eric: Offering points or bonus points is a fairly effective way for the government to deal with the long, sordid history of trying to get cybersecurity requirements into contracts. There’s been a ton of resistance from the contracting base, as you both know. And sometimes the call is coming from inside the house, with resistance from the government itself, from the SBA, or from the Department of War. So this is a very effective approach. The Department of Homeland Security did something similar, very quietly, a couple of years ago. It issued a notice on SAM.gov saying that in best-value awards, where it looks at factors like price, past performance, and technical ability, one factor would be how confident it is in your internal cybersecurity prowess, and that could be a deciding factor. I think that’s a big incentive for companies, as much as a regulatory requirement, because everyone is looking for a little advantage on a $100 million contract. If a $50,000 assessment is that advantage, they’ll do it and won’t think twice, and it’s easily justifiable. There are crazy stories about companies intercepting other companies’ proposals at FedEx locations. I can’t say more than that, but it’s a dog-eat-dog world. Everyone is trying to get a little advantage because there’s so much money at stake.
Jason: This might be the telling question that points to my intro, when I said I’m not qualified to answer any of these. Realistically, the person setting the scoring criteria is the customer. What gives anybody the right to protest the standard the customer sets for people who want to do business with them? They’re saying, “I want to award you extra points for cybersecurity because there’s justification and verification behind it, not your self-attestation.” Why is that an unfair advantage if I’m setting the standards, and there’s other scoring criteria, like proof of performance?
Eric: I don’t necessarily disagree with you, and that won’t stop me from filing a protest that says otherwise in the future. But all things being equal, and under this fact pattern, I don’t disagree. The customer has the right to set what it wants as the standard for what it’s buying, and it can justify it. The government is given wide berth when issuing a solicitation or deciding who to hire. The biggest problem it almost always has is that it doesn’t document or internally justify what it’s doing. Protests would be half as successful, or even a quarter as successful, if the government did a better job documenting and justifying its decisions.
Jason: You’d better keep it down.
Jacob: We’ll cut that.
Jason: We’ll cut that out. Geez, giving away the trade secrets here.
Does the Phase 2 Suspension Change the Legal Analysis?
Jacob: Let’s talk about the legal analysis, Eric. How does the Phase 2 suspension change it, particularly given the way GAO commented on reconsidering the scoring criteria?
Eric: As long as the agency isn’t asking for something contrary to any law or rule, and has given everyone equal notice of the requirement, it’s fine. Perhaps it wants to add a new cybersecurity control to a procurement because it’s important to the work, and it justifies that through documentation in the solicitation and adequate market research. Those hoops are fewer now with the Revolutionary FAR Overhaul that’s discussed in this case. The documentation requirements are lighter and the flexibility is greater, so protests like these will get even harder as the overhaul cascades through the government. In general, if it’s not unlawful, they can do it as long as they justify it. I think GAO didn’t quite say that here, but at least in my read, it got very close. Even after the suspension happened, GAO didn’t go back to the agency and say it had to take this back. There were some technical reasons for that, but I think GAO would have overlooked them if it saw a substantive basis to do so.
Jacob: The Phase 2 suspension is about stopping Level 2 certification as a condition of award. MAPS was structured so that if you have Level 2, you get more points, not that you must have it to get the award. I think that’s what this all hinges on.
Eric: Right.
Could DoD Reward Higher Cybersecurity Standards?
Jacob: Those bonus points are a really effective way to do this without raising hands. How far can the DoD extend this approach? Could different branches, services, or program offices award points for Level 3 over Level 2? Could they offer preferential points for controls that aren’t in the baselines? Listen up, contract offices: if you require additional controls beyond the baseline of your own volition, I will eat my shoe on this show, because I’d be stunned. Is this a viable approach going forward?
Eric: First of all, I wonder what condiments you use when you’re eating a shoe. [laughter]
Jason: I wanted to interject, because at some point we’re going to have to see him eat a shoe on the show. He’s said it a thousand times.
Eric: And not a flip-flop.
Jason: Right, a full-on shoe. A boot.
Eric: One of those cowboy boots. Unless you’re vegetarian, in which case that’s not a good idea. In a general sense, nothing stops contracting officers from doing that. Organizationally, they probably won’t, unless they get explicit internal permission, and that’s a long process. If they did, I think they’d first issue an RFI asking for feedback on adding certain controls because they’re vital given the information exchanged or created during performance. I’m sure some protesters would argue it’s unlawful because it goes beyond the requirements, but contracting officers and agencies put things in solicitations all the time that go beyond what’s absolutely required at a minimum.
Jacob: The bonus point structure isn’t part of the CMMC regulation. It didn’t go through rulemaking, and it’s nowhere in the CMMC program documents. It’s unique to the people who designed MAPS. So can different solicitations have different bonus point structures, with no bonus points or more bonus points, so that status is evaluated differently from solicitation to solicitation?
Eric: Sure, and that’s what happens all the time. Solicitations are decided on different merits every day. Price gets more weight on one, and technical gets more on another. On Level 3, the difficulty with requiring it is the availability of DIBCAC. Will contractors have equal opportunity to get a Level 3 assessment from DIBCAC? That’s one thing that could stop an agency. A Level 2 C3PAO assessment, on the other hand, anybody can go get tomorrow.
Jacob: So because Level 2 is available on the free market, it’s a more even playing field, whereas Level 3 is constricted to DIBCAC.
Eric: Right. If DIBCAC said it would assess anybody tomorrow, that could change the calculus, but that’s not how it’s been, or how it is right now.
Contract Consolidation and Small Business Competition
Jason: I want to shift gears. GAO also addressed consolidation and small business competition within MAPS. Where’s the legal line between acquisition efficiency and unfairly restricting competition?
Eric: It depends on which case you read, because they’re all very specific. I’ve brought bundling protests before. Some succeeded and some didn’t, and sometimes it surprises me what works. A court with 20 judges has 20 sets of beliefs and biases. I’ve gone to the Court of Federal Claims with a case I thought wouldn’t go well and drew a judge inclined to believe the legal argument, and vice versa, with what looked like a slam dunk and the one judge who didn’t buy it. It’s the same at GAO. Attorneys there have different levels of experience and backgrounds. GAO does a pretty good job of being consistent, but initial takes will differ, even on bundling. The bundling rules exist because it’s easier for contracting officers to combine a bunch of work rather than run five procurements and get one reliable large contractor. That alone isn’t necessarily a good enough reason. In this protest, GAO pointed out that there were spots reserved for small businesses, so the bundling argument fell flat. One protester argued that a small business prime can’t do this work because it’s a $50 billion procurement. GAO pointed out, probably correctly, that it’s $50 billion at its top level, but no one prime has to handle that, since there will be task orders. And though less than if it hadn’t been bundled, there are still spots reserved for small businesses. And, though this wasn’t in the decision, what’s even a small business anymore? The SBA has proposed changing the small business rules and NAICS codes, so you can have a million-dollar small business.
Jason: It’s Small Business Month. Shop at Lockheed.
Jacob: It’s funny you mention the subjective nature of how a judge is feeling and how they interpret the law. It’s like an assessor interpreting how your control implementation meets the control.
What Contractors Should Learn From MAPS
Jacob: What should contractors take away from MAPS, both when deciding whether to pursue CMMC certification and when evaluating their next major IDIQ opportunity?
Eric: A great question. First, a CMMC certification is never a bad idea if you can afford it and have the budget. It helps with teaming partners and primes, and depending on what the CIO does, it could help or it could become a requirement. We just don’t know yet. For a relatively low cost it could help your business. I know folks are concerned about the cost of the assessment, but study after study has shown it’s much smaller than the cost of getting controls in place, which contractors have to do anyway. Whether they’ve all done it is a story for another episode.
Jacob: Plenty of previous episodes.
Eric: On IDIQs, get in early and understand the direction. This bonus point structure was probably not first dropped in the final solicitation. It was probably ruminating during the RFI process. These things usually aren’t a surprise. If people in your pipeline share the solicitation internally with compliance, legal, or outside counsel, you can work out what you need to do to maximize points. Maybe a year ago, they’d have seen that a Level 2 certification requirement was coming, and thought, “We’d better get on top of that,” so you’re not left protesting after the fact or when the final solicitation is due.
Jacob: This has been really great perspective, and we’ll link to the protest document and the decision below. Everybody should take a look, because GAO doesn’t mince words about what matters and what doesn’t. Two questions on the way out, Eric. Do you have any general advice for contractors in the wake of the decision? And the DoD has said it wants to reward contractors that have achieved Level 2. Do you think we’ll see it pursue bonus points for certifications rather than conditions for award?
Eric: Taking the second question first, I can certainly see that as an option. Maybe they narrow the scope of what requires a C3PAO assessment at Level 2, and for those not required to get one, award points instead. None of us know what they’ll do. I love GAO as a venue because the folks there write in a clear and concise manner, and unlike a court case that can go on for years, decisions have to come out within 100 days of filing. I had court cases in New York that went on for 10 years and lived long after I moved out.
Jacob: That’s enough time to implement 171.
Eric: Almost. GAO is a refreshing way for businesses to operate, because they get certainty very quickly. For the general landscape, and this isn’t legal advice, the folks looking for work for their companies need to connect internally, not just find the work and ask for a solicitation response a few days before it’s due. Work hand in glove with the rest of the leadership team, particularly compliance and legal. Dealing with these issues on the front end ensures success on the back end.
Jacob: If you aren’t following Eric on LinkedIn, you’re wrong. He always posts great information, he’s easy to get ahold of, and you can find him on our podcast a bunch. I’ve been on your podcast, Eric, and you’re putting out great content from your firm. We’ll include a link to your profile below. Thanks for stopping by to explain this GAO decision. I have a feeling this gives the DoD a convenient way forward: encouraging certifications without technically requiring them. Maybe this discussion is a preview of what’s coming. Like and subscribe for more interviews with Eric, the great and powerful Crusius, and we’ll see you next week.
Jason: See you next week.
Eric: Thank you.
Contact
Speak With Our Team
Our team of compliance and cybersecurity experts are on standby and ready to help. We’ll walk you through what you need and what to expect.
